Selling Privately

Selling your car privately can be the most lucrative option if you're willing to put in the time and effort. In a private sale, you set the price and can negotiate directly with the buyer, meaning there’s potential for a higher selling price compared to a dealership or car-buying service. However, this process involves more effort, including listing the car, communicating with potential buyers, and managing the sale process from start to finish.

The private sale process can be more difficult because you’ll have to handle the legal paperwork, meet with buyers, and sometimes wait longer to find the right one. You’ll also need to be prepared for negotiations and the potential for low-ball offers. Plus, you’ll need to handle any issues that come up, such as dealing with test drives or buyers backing out.

Advantages:

Higher Selling Price: Private sales often yield higher prices, as you're selling directly to consumers without intermediaries.​

Negotiation Flexibility: You have the autonomy to negotiate terms and price directly with buyers.​


Considerations:

Time and Effort: Listing the car, arranging viewings, and handling negotiations can be time-consuming.​

Safety and Security: Meeting strangers and handling payments require caution to avoid scams or fraud.​

Paperwork: You're responsible for all legal documentation, including the bill of sale and title transfer.​

Interesting Fact: In September 2024, approximately 627,700 used vehicles were sold in the UK, marking a 5% year-over-year increase from September 2023.

Selling to a buying service

A car-buying service like We Buy Cars Hexham offers an easy and quick option for selling your car, typically with a straightforward process that can often be done online or with a few phone calls. The benefit of using a buying service is the convenience and speed. You'll usually get an offer in a matter of hours, and once you accept, the transaction can often be completed on the same day.

Unlike dealerships, car-buying services have a wider scopes of what they buy, regardless of condition, age, or mileage. They may also be interested in cars with significant mechanical and bodywork issues which often fall outside dealerships purchase criteria. The advantage here is that it’s a simple process—no negotiations, no haggling, and no waiting around for potential buyers. The downside, though, is that you may not get as high a price as you would in a private sale.

Dealership

Selling your car to a dealership can be an easy and quick process, but it’s not always the best option if you're aiming for the highest price. Dealerships often focus on certain types of cars that fit their inventory needs. For example, some may only purchase vehicles with fewer than 70,000 miles or those with a full main dealer service history. Others, like import specialists, may only be interested in certain makes or models, leaving your car out of their purchasing scope.

Dealerships typically offer a trade-in value, which might be lower than the private sale price, but it reflects the fact that they are taking on the risk of reselling the car. Some dealers may be willing to accept a car as a part-exchange but not as a straight buy-in, especially if it doesn’t fit their stock profile. The reason? Dealerships often have a higher profit margin on cars sold as part-exchanges because they can bundle the sale with the purchase of another vehicle. This inflated margin allows them to offer you a slightly higher part-exchange price compared to a straight buy-in.

However, dealerships can offer convenience, speed, and an easy process, particularly if you’re looking to trade up for another vehicle.