Skip to main content
Please enter your registration.
✓No obligation

How We Actually Value Your Car

4 min read
author
BY
Chris Walker
How We Actually Value Your Car

Most buyers will not tell you how they actually reach the number they offer for your car. It is usually presented as a finished figure, take it or leave it, with no explanation of what went into it. We think that is the wrong way round, so this is the plain explanation of how we actually work it out.

The Four Things We Actually Look At

We do not run your reg through a single algorithm and call it a day. We build a figure from four live sources, looked at together rather than any one in isolation:

  • Comparable Autotrader listings, so we know what similar cars are genuinely being advertised for right now, not what they sold for months ago.
  • Live auction prices, which tell us what trade buyers are actually paying for stock like yours, not what a dealer hopes to retail it at.
  • Live trade-in values from dealer part-exchange data, a different angle on demand to auction pricing.
  • Part-exchange values, blended in alongside the three above so no single source carries the whole decision.

A single source can be wrong in either direction. An asking price can be optimistic. An auction result can be a one-off. Looking at all four together is what lets us land on a figure that reflects what the car is actually worth, not what one tool guessed.

Why We Price for Average Condition, Not Showroom Condition

We start from the position that your car has had real, average wear and tear. We are not assuming it has sat in a locked, heated garage on a trickle charger since the day it was registered. Most cars have not, and pricing as if they had is exactly what leads to a number that gets cut once someone actually looks at the car.

That is why the figure we give you at the triage stage is the figure we pay in 93% of the deals we complete. We would rather build a fair number properly the first time than offer a high headline figure and cut it once we see the car.

How We Price for Known Faults, Not Against Them

Where a car has a genuine fault, we would rather price for it honestly upfront than discover it on the day and use it as a reason to lower the offer. We keep a working knowledge of common, recurring problems on specific makes and models, for example certain Vauxhall gearbox issues and certain Mini head gasket and coolant leak issues. We price that risk into the figure we give you from the start, rather than treating a fault as a surprise to renegotiate around later.

What We Don't Do

We don't price your car as if it were the best example of its kind and then walk that back once we see it. We don't ask you a short set of questions online and treat the answer as gospel regardless of what a proper inspection would find. If you have already had an online quote cut once someone actually saw your car, our separate guide on what to do when that happens covers it directly.

When This Process Isn't the Right Fit for Your Car

We are not the right buyer for every car. If yours is a genuinely rare or exceptional example, a specialist dealer or an auction built for that type of car may get you a stronger number than a general buyer, us included. Our method is built for the ordinary used car market, where comparables, auction data and trade-in values actually mean something.

Next Steps

If you want a figure built the way described above, send us the registration and we will work it out properly before we ever come to see the car. If you are happy with it, we come to you, inspect the car, and the figure on screen is the figure we pay.

Common Questions

How do you work out how much to offer for my car?

We blend four live sources together: comparable Autotrader listings, live auction prices, live trade-in values, and part-exchange values. No single source decides the figure on its own.

Do you assume my car is in perfect condition?

No. We start from the position that your car has had real, average wear and tear, not showroom condition. That is why our figure tends to hold once we actually see the car.

What if my car has a known fault?

We price for it honestly from the start, using what we already know about common faults on specific makes and models, rather than discovering it on the day and lowering the offer.

Why does your offer sometimes differ from an online instant quote?

Instant quotes are usually built from a handful of basics and a few questions you answer yourself. Ours is built from four live market data sources and an honest assumption about condition, which is a different starting point and can produce a different, more durable number.

author
About the author
Chris Walker
Chris Walker joined We Buy Cars Hexham in 2019 after eight years in automotive retail across the North East. He's handled over 2,000 vehicle valuations and specialises in salvage assessments and fleet disposals. Chris grew up in Haltwhistle and knows every back road between Hadrian's Wall and the A69. When he's not pricing Astras, he's restoring a Series 3 Land Rover that hasn't run since 2016.
Google reviews ★★★★★ 5.0
Leave a review Leave us a review